77th Emmy Awards
Sep. 14th, 2025 07:17 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Just like last year, I've managed to watch at least one episode of every show nominated for a Primetime Emmy Award, including the specific episodes nominated in the writing and directing categories (but not counting the reality/variety categories). Once again I don't have enough time left before the ceremony tonight to write up my opinions of each show, but here are my rankings in each category from most to least favorite. (These are not predictions, just how I would fill out my ballot if I were in the Television Academy.) I've indicated how many episodes I've watched of each show; for the ones with no indication, I watched the full season. (For multiple-season shows that were new to me, I watched the pilot episode first. In the case of Somebody Somewhere, I watched the first and last episodes of the series, since the finale was nominated for Outstanding Writing, so it felt like I was on Alan Sepinwall's Too Long; Didn't Watch podcast!)
Outstanding Comedy Series
- The Bear (FX)
- The Studio (Apple TV+) - 5 episodes
- Hacks (HBO Max) - 4 episodes
- Abbott Elementary (ABC) - 8 episodes
- Nobody Wants This (Netflix)
- Only Murders in the Building (Hulu)
- Shrinking (Apple TV+)
- What We Do in the Shadows (FX) - 2 episodes
While none of these shows were home runs (and not the best season for any of the returning shows), they were all worth watching, and it's honestly hard to rank them.
Outstanding Drama Series
- Andor (Disney+)
- Slow Horses (Apple TV+)
- Severance (Apple TV+)
- The Pitt (HBO Max) - 4 episodes
- The White Lotus (HBO)
- The Diplomat (Netflix) - 1 episode
- Paradise (Hulu) - 2 episodes
- The Last of Us (HBO) - 1 episode
While I ranked Severance over Andor in my best TV of 2022 list, it was a very close call. After their second seasons, though, I'm ready to call Andor the clear winner, and the clear leader for best show of the decade. Unfortunately it doesn't seem like it's going to win, but you should all watch it! Even if you hate Star Wars!
Everyone says episode 7 of Paradise is the one to watch, but I haven't gotten there yet. Looking forward to it, but from what I hear, the rest of the season is unlikely to change my rating. And I think the same goes for episode 2 of The Last of Us, but I already was lukewarm on season 1 (ranking 49th in my best TV of 2023 list), so you shouldn't be too surprised to see it ranked last here.
Outstanding Limited or Anthology Series
- The Penguin (HBO)
- Adolescence (Netflix)
- Black Mirror (Netflix) - 2 episodes
- Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story (Netflix)
- Dying for Sex (FX) - 6 episodes
All worthy shows, and while Dying for Sex didn't totally land for me, I can see its appeal for many others. I was skeptical about Monsters but after episode 5 I understood why it was nominated, and it's worth watching the show just to see how it gets to that. I regret not getting around to the other Black Mirror episodes, but the first two felt a little lower than average compared to past seasons.
( Read more... )